this post was submitted on
30 points (78% like it)
41 up votes 11 down votes
all 18 comments

[–]Arkaic 6 points7 points ago*

This was such an incredibly underrated album. I think a lot of people just wanted something Panda Bear-ish, and they got a deeply personal, atmospheric, and sonically different album instead. They were probably disappointed and didn't give it the thoughtful listen it deserved, so a lot of people just kind of dismissed it.

One of my favorites of 2010 definitely. Glad to see someone else spreading the love :)

[–]OutSanity 0 points1 point ago

I agree, I don't like much of Panda Bear's solo stuff for the purpose of it sounding kind of like you're in a metal room, not very "earthy". As opposed to AnCo or Avey Tare's solo stuff, it sounds more forest-y and psychedelic. Though on Down There, it sounds like music coming from the depths of a swamp or something, it's interesting.

[–]tabelz 0 points1 point ago

I think Person Pitch is INCREDIBLY earthy.

[–]OutSanity 1 point2 points ago

I can dig Person Pitch, but Tomboy totally just gives off that "metal-box" feel.

[–]lleeeeeoo 2 points3 points ago

Great post, very in-depth. A few months ago my friend invited me to come with them to see Avey Tare in Los Angeles but I turned down the offer seeing as Panda Bear and the whole Animal Collective thing isn't really my thing but reading this, I kind of wish I went now.

[–]Enage 0 points1 point ago

Very nice review, I've always preferred Panda Bear to Avey but it was still a good album.

[–]m00dawg 0 points1 point ago

I'll have to check them out! Thanks for the great review - not a band I have ever heard of and vinyl release seems pretty hot!

[–]thisisbray 1 point2 points ago

Love this record. I listen to it all the time.

[–]bonnaventure 0 points1 point ago

I loved this album, but am a bit annoyed at the sleeve being an awkward size.

[–]aroomacanvas 1 point2 points ago

Very well done and thorough review. Personally, I was disappointed by this album, and I thought it didn't live up to my expectations for Animal Collective's work, but to each his own.

[–]screamingtrees 1 point2 points ago

Here's another cool video from the album: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HMk2vONzTNk&feature=fvsr

[–]Cinelli -4 points-3 points ago

avant-garde

There's nothing avant-garde about Animal Collective. If anything, their older work is more freak folkish than anything else and you might be able to call them somewhat experimental. That said, I'm glad that you enjoyed the album (I've never really been able to get into Animal Collective or any side projects) and I'm actually a bit jealous, because it sounds like it's a phenomenal pressing.

[–]xtatik222k[S] 2 points3 points ago

It's definitely experimental. at the time I couldnt think of a better term, hence the brackets.

[–]heavypettingzoos 1 point2 points ago

They're considered avant garde because they're at the front of the pack in terms of developing new directions or further cultivating established precedents in their respective genre. It's always used to refer to people who make innovative and influential strides in art through experimentation. So in their pop-art category, it works

[–]screamingtrees 1 point2 points ago

Have you heard Hollinndagain and Animal Crack Box? Experimental.

[–]tabelz 1 point2 points ago

Or seen ODDSAC, or listened to Here Comes the Indian, or listened to Danse Manatee?

[–]screamingtrees 0 points1 point ago

Yes it concerns me how much I even see the word 'pop' going on this conversation. I would analyze them as being far closer to art music than anything else. Even if you are looking at albums like Merriweather, I'd say electronic is a better descriptor, or freak folk for Sung Tongs through Strawberry Jam. But for their music as a whole I really only feel comfortable with experimental or the like.

[–]MoonWatcher88 1 point2 points ago

I like to describe AnCo's music as pop deconstruction. It's as if they break down the tonalities, chords, and structure of pop music, play with it, and mold it into something completely new. Of course they use a lot of strange sampled sounds and effects along with that. Imagine taking your favorite moment in a pop song and stretching it out for several minutes into a auditory playground where you can experiment with a myriad of harmonies, sounds, and layers...well that's how I think of AnCo's music. This approach also lends itself to the psychedelic nature of the music. This is all just my opinion though.