this post was submitted on
36 points (92% like it)
39 up votes 3 down votes
all 19 comments

[–]Deimorz 8 points9 points ago

The game SpaceChem does this ("discussion" link at the top).

[–]PotatoMusicBinge[S] 1 point2 points ago

Cheers, pm'd him to see what the legal story is

[–]PartyRob 4 points5 points ago

I'd like to know this, too. I just created a subreddit for my webcomic and we're speccing out a complete website redesign. We're going to invite a lot of articles and fan content submissions to our main blog stream, and I would love to use the subreddit as a kind of submission queue and up/downvote crucible for organizing that stuff. I'd like to literally embed the subreddit in the new site, for that.

I couldn't find in the TOS whether or not this would be okay. Any idea who I could contact about it?

[–]hueypriest 7 points8 points ago

We do allow it, but a "submission que" scares me. If it's for discussion, feedback, etc then great! If it's only links going a certain site, then that's another animal. Something like /r/spacechem would be awesome. hadn't seen that before, but looks like an excellent way to use a subreddit to me.

[–]PartyRob 3 points4 points ago

No it wouldn't be just links to the comic site. It would be the opposite of that, if anything. People would post their fan fiction, art, comics, videos, etc. there as a way of letting other fans sort out the great from the terrible. Then we would mirror the best stuff from that process in our blogs for fan stuff, fiction, and gaming stuff, and reward the creators with store credit. Later, we might buy rights to art and stories to publish them in book form. Win-win.

[–]hueypriest 7 points8 points ago

Sounds pretty great. Hope it works out well.

[–]unfortunatejordan 0 points1 point ago

If it's only links going a certain site, then that's another animal.

Would you mind elaborating on this? I post links from my site to my subreddit, about once a week or so, but each time I imagine the spam filter scowling at me.

[–]PotatoMusicBinge[S] 0 points1 point ago

If it's for discussion, feedback, etc then great!

Cool, thats pretty much what I was thinking

[–]turnyouracslaterup 2 points3 points ago

Was disappointed by the lack of fat pet photos on /r/fatpets.

[–]PotatoMusicBinge[S] 1 point2 points ago

Some day a better man than me will make your dream a reality

[–]unfortunatejordan 3 points4 points ago

I have done this to a degree, although calling myself a commercial enterprise is quite a stretch, since it's just me. I have a subreddit which basically serves as a forum for my site. I chose reddit over a dedicated forum because I believe reddit has a better system than a traditional bulletin board.

I can't see an issue with it, even in the case of a large company, as long as they follow the rules like everyone else, no sockpuppets, no vote gaming etc. I don't think any company could gain enough subscribers to compete for an /r/all spot, even on a good day. (edit - meaning an officially-run subreddit, rather than a community-run one like /r/starcraft or /r/minecraft)

Several large subreddits already exist without direct involvement, /r/apple and /r/xkcd spring to mind. I'm not quite sure where to place them, they're somewhere inbetween regular communities and officially-run communities.

I imagine that most large companies prefer not to have such a public forum, directly on a social networking site, as they'd see it as a risk.

This comment is a bit all over the place. I should get some breakfast.

[–]PotatoMusicBinge[S] 0 points1 point ago

I imagine that most large companies prefer not to have such a public forum, directly on a social networking site, as they'd see it as a risk.

I remember hearing something about official paid subreddits a while ago, maybe it didnt go ahead for those reasons? Id say /r/godaddy, for example, is glad it dosent exist:)

[–]perceptionsofpacha 0 points1 point ago

Since you posted someone has created it. Perhaps related?

[–]PotatoMusicBinge[S] 0 points1 point ago

Nah it was there already, but im betting the company didnt put it there themselves:D

[–]Gimli_The_Dwarf 2 points3 points ago

I wouldn't. If the company likes the reddit format, then you can get the reddit source code and install it on your own server.

If you make a subreddit your official company support site, then you're opening the company to liability for anything posted there. Imagine waking up one morning to find out that someone decided it would be cute to post a whole bunch of porn to your subreddit...

[–]syuk 2 points3 points ago

Mods can approve submitters, so if a customer registers on your external website, you setup the account and allow posts (perhaps prefixing the account name, e.g SYUKINC_Gimli or somesuch).

The way moderators can be added and worldwide without depending on your own infrastructure is also a boon.

Reddit gets ad / page views, I think this could work for some applications.

[–]go1dfish 0 points1 point ago

Imagine waking up one morning to find out that someone decided it would be cute to post a whole bunch of porn to your subreddit...

How is this any different from if someone chose to do the same with your self-hosted reddit?

btw, ASCII (well full unicode actually) porn is the only porn reddit will host.

But they can link of course.

[–]metabeing 4 points5 points ago*

In a way I do this for http://gifsound.com by using Reddit's widgets.

[–]PotatoMusicBinge[S] 1 point2 points ago

This is great. My favourites: this this and this