this post was submitted on
87 points (58% like it)
296 up votes 209 down votes
top 200 commentsshow all 489

[–]JunaCentauri 29 points30 points ago

Don't think I've ever seen an IAMA where the poster gets net negative karma.

[–]majinjohnny 17 points18 points ago

Yeah this IAMA isn't going so well.

[–]abrahamlinco1n 2 points3 points ago

I don't know about that- its possible to disagree and still obtain insight into a topic and a region of the world that is not often shown.

[–]Vultatio -2 points-1 points ago

There's not much insight from his responses, though. So far the gist of it seems to be 'Capitalists imperial american swine are ruining my country! communism is the only way everything will be perfect. Die american conspiracy pigs!'

He sounds like a mouthpiece for Ahmadinejad or Chávez.

Not very insightful or eye opening to his cause or decisions in my opinion, which I would actually like to hear about if this were real.

Doesn't sound like he actually knows what he;s talking about.

[–]Galinaceo 3 points4 points ago

I don't know about Ahmadinajad, but Chavez isnt a nutty. Watch "The Revolution is not going to be Televisioned", which is too pro-Chavez, but keep looking until you know the two sides.

just sayin´

[–]aktsukikeeper 1 point2 points ago

The Paul Christoforo one panned quite badly if I remember correctly.

[–]majinjohnny 0 points1 point ago

He did an AMA? Sheit, gotta look that one up.

Then read an eighth of it.

Then begin browsing /r/funny

[–]1984comment 2 points3 points ago

It's because it's totally fake.

[–]NopeChomsky 4 points5 points ago

"IAMA TERRORIST WHO BELIEVES IN A SYSTEM OF GOVERNANCE WHOSE TRACK RECORD IS LITERALLY WORSE THAN HITLER'S."

Yeah, I'm astounded too.

[–]SilentExchange 4 points5 points ago

Communism isn't the problem, it's the leaders that are the problem. If you actually read what communism is supposed to accomplish it actually sounds better than some current governments. However, when put into practice the leaders are always too corrupt to carry out correct communism.

[–]jaki_cold 10 points11 points ago

  • communism
  • leaders

Um.

[–][deleted] 4 points5 points ago

Yes, so shall we put you in charge? That will solve it.

[–]SilentExchange 2 points3 points ago

Yup!

[–]FuggleyBrew 0 points1 point ago

Even if they weren't corrupt (good luck amassing that much power and not having corrupt leaders though) allocating an entire economies resources is to complex to do from a top down perspective.

[–]Ironyz 0 points1 point ago

that is one form of communism, the stalinist variety. the others are generally more akin to anarchy. look it up.

[–]FuggleyBrew -1 points0 points ago

The others are more akin to unicorns and fairy tales.

[–]Galinaceo 2 points3 points ago

Socialism worked well in Cuba.

[–]Moh7 5 points6 points ago

Socialism =\= communism

[–]Socialist_Asshole 2 points3 points ago

Truth ^

[–]xxdelta77xx 0 points1 point ago

Word.

[–]Soomin 27 points28 points ago

I have a friend who is part Filipino and looks white. When she visits her family in more rural areas, she says that her grandmother has to hide her when the NPA is in the area for fear of being abducted.

Does this happen / normal to see?

[–]manicpoohbear 7 points8 points ago

My husband is white, and my mother/grandmother fretted for years about whether it's safe to have him visit the area where they live. But things have cooled down in that part, so they were fine with us staying in that region for a while though. It still made me nervous when he got random stares from groups of guys though.

[–]infernalspacemonkey 7 points8 points ago

Yes, this happens. I too have family in the PI and the NPA are described as 'armed thugs'.

[–]Awkward_Arab 20 points21 points ago

You guys are idiots for believing this guy is legit.

[–]BCBUDDHA 2 points3 points ago

True this.. Proof im sure would be easy enough to provide.

i mean shit, even some guy posing with his Airsoft AK47 would get considered legit, this guy couldn't even do that

[–]statusquoexile 63 points64 points ago*

I lived in a town in Eastern Samar for a time back in 2000. You guys ambushed and murdered 8 soldiers from the Philippine National Army while I was there. Young soldiers, and some who had families. Are you proud of your group's actions?

Some more info from my first hand experience living there:

The NPA in this region lives and hides in the jungle to avoid the government. According to the locals who live there, the NPA are viewed as an idealistic group with no real agenda other than arbitrarily going against the Gov't. They steal from and kill National Army soldiers. Now the Gov't in the Philippines is corrupt, everyone knows that, but so is the NPA. The locals have no faith in their Gov't, and have an equal disdain for the NPA because they do not fight for the good of the people, they fight for thier own idealistic communist agenda.

Please people, understand that this group causes more trouble for the avergae citizen than good. This is not some honourable rebellion taking jabs at an oppressive and corrupt Gov't. This is a muderous, selfish, oblivious group of whackjobs pursuing a communist agenda against a corrupt government, only making the lives of the innocent civilian more difficult.

Upvoted for more attention.

sorry, more grammar edits Too much hasty typing I guess. This topic really hits home....I've lived amongst the average citizen fighting to survive day to day. The NPA is a corrupt group making life more difficult for the everyday hard-working citizen through illegal parasitic taxes enforced with threats of violence, death and persecution among other challenges.

[–]alquanna 20 points21 points ago

Apologies for hijacking this comment: to be fair, OP sounds very, very fake. Not one sentence about agrarian reform? I know a lot of people from the left (not yet NPA-level, but I do have a friend that was captured by the Army and later released) and OP doesn't sound like it.

Also, the picture that he used is actually a picture of Ka Roger, who was once the spokesperson for the NPA. Original picture here. Unfortunately, he's dead.

[–]albinocheetah 2 points3 points ago

As soon as I saw this thread I googled that picture then tried to wrap my head around why everyone else hadn't done the same.

[–]punninglinguist 1 point2 points ago

Do you mean you tineye'd that picture, or is there some way to do a reverse google image search?

[–]albinocheetah 2 points3 points ago

go to google.com/images, in the right side of the search bar there's a blue camera, click on that and put in the url

[–]punninglinguist 1 point2 points ago

Nice. Thank you!

[–]alquanna -1 points0 points ago

For me, I recognized the guy, and did a Google image search for Ka Roger. That image came up in the second page. xD

[–]mootchell 1 point2 points ago

As soon as I saw this thread I googled that picture then tried to wrap my head around how a dead man was doing an AMA.

[–]spast17 1 point2 points ago

I believe that picture is actually Ka Oris (Comrade Oris.) Who is still alive. However, I always imagined someone like Ka Oris who is an official spokesman to be much more eloquent than this fool of an OP. The OP reeks of bullshit.

Therefore, I would like to request a real IAMA with the REAL Ka Oris.

[–]ApolloAbove 12 points13 points ago

This is a surreal post, and I thank you for giving your time to speak. As an outsider, and an American, I can't really say I support you, or your cause, but I can ask you about why you feel that armed resistance against the government is a better option then peaceful protest and arguing for peaceful political change? It would be interesting to hear from the other side.

[–][deleted] 11 points12 points ago

dude, government in PI is horrible. Elected officials literally pay for votes.

[–]PucktheFauxlice 9 points10 points ago

how is this different from the US again ?

[–]fvf 8 points9 points ago

Less impressive PR.

[–]NewPeoplesArmy[S] 0 points1 point ago

When the government is corrupt, it must be remove from power. Negotiation won't work because this corrupt officials will continue to steal.They must be removed through force.

[–]dave_L 7 points8 points ago

Let me ask one matter of concern - your NDF panel had been negotiating with the government since the time of Ramos administration and yet no concrete results were ever established. For each & every successive Manila administrations that came into power & in every round of appointed negotiating panel members nary a concrete result materialized. And yet, neither your CPP side of negotiators produced any.

Is it because the CPP side of the negotiators were in cahoots with the corrupt elements of every gov't-appointed members just to bilk the process as long as it can, if not forever? Have you as comrades-in-arms ever wonder why?

Assuming, as you mentioned, that NPA and you considered the gov't as corrupt, then why has there never been any reports of liquidation/kidnapping of gov't panel negotiators... given NPAs' notoriety & penchant for liquidating corrupt officials? Why has no one among you NPA folks ever questioned, dissent or investigate your panel-members on such appalling track records of peace negotiations?

[–]ApolloAbove 1 point2 points ago

Thank you for answering. If you had caught this corruption before it was a problem, would you have acted differently?

[–]golfingmadman 1 point2 points ago

Except when Manny is fighting. Then, the PI is at peace.

[–]flyladyj 11 points12 points ago

Mabuhay! Kumusta ka? Maajo dinhi.

I lived in the Philippines for 2 years. The government is awful and corrupt from the SK level. However I feel like the NPA is just as corrupt. Imposing "taxes" on aid workers who are trying to bring clean water to the poor people you speak about...that's bullshit. You're taking money away from those people and that project. I can't support the NPA in it's current incarnation.

The mayor of my town was involved in the NPA in Davao in the 80s when he was a priest and he was imprisoned for several years for speaking out against Marcos. He said that the NPA of today is more of a stick-up group against foreigners more than anything. I'd have to say I agree with him.

[–]Jeff_E_Popp 14 points15 points ago

You are a member of the Rebel Alliance and a traitor.

[–]texting_and_scones 2 points3 points ago

If you hadn't joined the NPA what would you be doing? How do your parents, family, and friends outside the NPA feel about you being a rebel fighter?

[–]Galinaceo 21 points22 points ago

People, whether we agree or disagree with the OP, I think it is a unique opportunitty to learn about some distant culture and way of life. I would beg for a moderator to confirm too.

[–]brownAir 15 points16 points ago

Yes, can't tell if trolling or real communist rebel.

[–]casual_geek 11 points12 points ago*

I'm a Filipino that had my childhood in the Philippines. I have been living here in Canada since I was 14. There's been times when we were stopped by the NPA when my dad would drive us from Manila to Bicol. Since my dad was a cop, they never much bothered us. I also remember military checks during our 12+ hour road trip just to make sure we're not harboring NPA rebels.

Oh the NPA. Your political agenda hasn't made any serious strides since the late 80's. I don't think you understand your purpose anymore. All this talk about spreading wealth to the Filipino people blah blah. All your talks about how foreigners that need to leave the Philippines. Granted the country's social system (healthcare, education, pensions, etc.) is very flawed and that needs to be fixed. But going about your way isn't going to make the Philippines a much better place to live.

If you somehow manage to overthrow the government and started implementing this... "spread the wealth to all Filipinos," can you explain how exactly you are going to do this? Is there an actual plan as to how you are gonna be able to equally distribute the country's wealth to 93+ million Filipinos?

And the country's wealth you are talking about... That's the money that the Philippines owed to the International Monetary Fund. So what you are saying is that you want to spread, not just the country's wealth, but also the country's debt to the people. Is that really what you're planning to do?

[–]redme22 3 points4 points ago

Does your military have don't ask don't tell?

[–]ValerikScorn 17 points18 points ago

How do you feel about the United States Marine Corps having training missions in your country? As a Marine I just want to know.

[–]Galinaceo 18 points19 points ago

Seems like reddit hates communism...

[–]Ameisen 9 points10 points ago

I don't hate communism. Some would consider me a communist. The NPA, however, paints communists in a negative light. They are what people hate about their perception of communism, because they are some people's perception of communism... roaming, thieving bands.

[–]fiat_lux_ 5 points6 points ago

The NPA is par for the course for a national level communist uprising.

Populist movements aren't exactly known for rule of law and organization. One of the main reasons they start is because the people feel that the current system (including the laws) needs an overhaul.

[–]Ameisen -1 points0 points ago

If you are operating without clear organization and a concept of rule of law, then you are doing it wrong, if it's a communist uprising. Marx would be appalled at how the NPA operates. Whether or not the track record insofar for communist uprisings is similar to this is irrelevant, as no communist states that exists or has existed so far was "up to par" to an actual communist state, especially since most really more resembled Stalinist states.

[–]fiat_lux_ 2 points3 points ago

Nothing is done perfectly. The US has problems implement its own fundamental values espoused in the constitution.

Major communist movements throughout history have drawn their support from the lower classes. Did you expect lawyers or people with clear knowledge, conceptualization, and respect for rule of law, and the management/social skills to implement it?

As someone born in a communist country with many connections to people who've lived through it, I think what's being described here is par for the course. If you're waiting a communist uprising with "clear organization and concept of rule of law", then don't hold your breath.

[–]Ameisen 1 point2 points ago

As someone born in a communist country with many connections to people who've lived through it, I think what's being described here is par for the course. If you're waiting a communist uprising with "clear organization and concept of rule of law", then don't hold your breath.

I'm waiting for a non-Stalinist and non-Maoist uprising. I do not consider Stalinist and Maoist states to be Communist. They just tend to form oligarchies.

[–]fiat_lux_ 5 points6 points ago*

If you're imagining some sort of classless utopia, then let me remind you that that is an ultimate goal, and hardly realistic for what humans are now. Problem with these idealistic goals (stateless anarcho capitalism being another) is that they go against what is currently human nature. Collectivism and individualism are both inherent to our nature. Those idealistic goals might be achievable in the long run, when humans have sufficiently evolved or changed from what we are now.

You are hoping for smooth transitions when history (and, frankly, common sense) should have already been an indication that these things don't happen smoothly.

Where and why do communist uprisings tend to happen?

  • In places where most people are desperately poor and powerless

  • Most people don't trust the current gov't, laws, or entire system itself. To their credit, the system probably is corrupt as hell and difficult to legitimately and lawfully change for the better.

Who are involved in these uprisings?

  • Lower classes; peasants; and demagogues who rely on emotions, not laws and logic, since they want to FIRE people up, not douse their flames with boring, rational plans/discussion

What do you think is the logical consequence? Calm, lawful, non-violent uprising? Come on now.

Once they overthrow the existing institutions that were keeping them down, what do you think the populist movement is going to do? Will they rebuild society from scratch immediately, and produce a perfectly functioning, lawful society as well as gov't that people trust... using their [non-existent] legal education? No... of course not.

In the absence of system, stability, law... The amorphous blob of a mobocracy often just ends up creating cults of personality around central figures they can relate to. Thus, power naturally accumulates into a focal point. People naturally gravitate towards leaders, after all.

It's easy for you or others to call yourselves or describe yourselves as communists when you don't have to implement the systems involved. (Kind of like "innovators" who just come up with perfect ideas, and end up facing harsh realities as they implement them or leave the implementation to engineers and consultants.) You don't have to associate yourself with the communists who actually had to try and implement their ideas because you yourself and others haven't even started in the first place.

[–]Voidkom 0 points1 point ago

Couldn't agree more, fuck authoritarian communism.

[–]snarc 0 points1 point ago

Authoritarian communism would be where I'm forbidden to derive economic value from my own property, all means of production are instead held by some communal organisation, and this is enforced upon me by a man with a gun, yes?

Mind explaining how the other sort works? If not by a gun-toting authoritarian, how are you going to collectivise my property if I don't want you to?

[–]Voidkom 1 point2 points ago*

Because the property was never yours in the first place, you are in fact stealing the property from everybody else with the threat of a gun. I think a better question is: How are you going to keep the property you don't use if there is no military force to enforce your property rights?

In order to maximize individual freedom, everyone will have to be able to have their own property to use. This will be decided by the community for the community. And therefore this cannot happen without the consent of the community, and then there is no problem. And because there is no authoritarian state, you and the others who disagree can always go live in your own profit-based cut-throat community.

[–]snarc 0 points1 point ago

Ah, so if a particular local community does not support collectivisation of property, then it will not be enforced upon them? Glad to hear it. Form your own communes if you like, I wish you the best of luck, and I will keep what is mine and run it in the capitalist way. We'll see who does well.

Oh, wait...

the property was never yours in the first place

You intend to seize it at gunpoint, don't you?

[–]BrutalCassius 3 points4 points ago*

Has anyone in recent history painted communism in a positive light?

[–]mcglaven 3 points4 points ago

There is literally a wealth of marxist activism out there, but it is not represented well in the mainstream media. Try Slavoj Zizek (many great youtube vids) if you're really interested.

[–]Galinaceo 0 points1 point ago

Yes, if you dwell among social movements and activists, there are some places where you can't say that socialism is less then perfect or people will roll eyes on you.

[–]morris858 1 point2 points ago

Communism is an economic system that removes currency and people work on the trust system. Take what you need and do your job and everyone lives happy. People corrupt this idea by being greedy "what is one person not working and taking what they need?" which is why we as a species need to evolve a good bit before it is possible to use a similar system. The economic system is about as dangerous as any other, but people associate it with totalitarianism and fascism because of propaganda during WWII.

[–]snarc -1 points0 points ago

Amazing, that. I mean, you'd think we'd be able to see past all the millions of murders, the totalitarianism, the one party states, the insane personality cults, the disastrous policies and the restrictions on freedom of movement for anybody who quite reasonably wanted to get the hell out, you'd think we could just set that aside as irrelevant and see Communism for the democratic, humane and decent system it truly is. I'm ashamed of Reddit's irrational hate for a system that historically brought so much benefit to the world as compared to the tyrant capitalist system enforced by the Americans at gunpoint over the peace-loving workers of the West.

[–]Galinaceo 0 points1 point ago

Yeah, OP, as troll as he was, was right. Some people are "brainwashed by Capitalism" :P

I'm not even gonna argue with you. There is interesting discussion happening. Read it and learn something.

[–]snarc 0 points1 point ago*

Interesting discussion I have no problem with. All you Communists can discuss all you like, I wish you well. Form yourselves another International, and spend decades debating it. Write long theses explaining how the inevitable progress of history is on your side. Publish detailed explanations of the technical reasons why Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, Ceausescu, Tito, Castro, and the Kim dynasty were none of them really Communists at all. Pass motions. Flush them. Have fun.

But for the sake of humanity, I beg you, never, ever try to run a country again. Just keep on discussing.

[–]Galinaceo 0 points1 point ago

Do your homework.

[–]lpisme 3 points4 points ago

I've never heard of the NPA and I don't have an opinion either way - I was just curious, however: what would happen to you in the Philippines if you were captured?

Does the government there or elsewhere consider you domestic terrorists? Or is the NPA established in parts of the government? Judging by the fact you say you're an "armed wing" I would imagine that you'd face some serious consequences if caught.

[–]spast17 3 points4 points ago*

My hometown used to have an NPA problem. IIRC, they weren't normally captured, they were shot by troops on sight. Just as they would shoot government troops on sight.

The NPA were nothing more than thugs. They extorted "protection" money from the mayor. If the mayor didn't give, they threatened violence.

They also used to actively recruit students from the high school to come and fight for them. I'm thankful they have been driven from our area.

[–]phrozen1 4 points5 points ago

Hi there. First off, thanks for doing this AMA. While most of the US based Redditors might not know a lot of the details behind your movement and how your group is portrayed here in the Philippines, it's interesting nonetheless.

Based on your previous responses, I am curious to know how you feel about people such as myself... an American expatriate, living about half the year here in Manila. I'm also married to a Filipina (we're both in our 20s, FYI).

When we have traveled up north (Ilocos) to visit some of the extended family, I have heard of horror stories including uninvolved citizens getting caught in between gun battles between your group and the military. Is this justified in your opinion?

You obviously don't want foreign interference in your country, so what would you do to me if you found me hanging out in the barrio smoking some Bowling Golds and drinking Beer Na Beer? Shoot me? Kidnap me? Extortion? Or would you take a more diplomatic approach and engage me in thoughtful conversation? Just curious.

[–]PucktheFauxlice 4 points5 points ago

If we go to the philippines to visit, do we have to worry about getting kidnapped? just because we're tourists?

and if we do get kidnapped, are we given a chance to let you know whether or not we actually agree with you or are we just automatically the enemy and beyond redemption?

[–]wowwhataman 2 points3 points ago

nah. unless you go to mindanao -- with the exception of davao, chances are, you're safe.

and if you're white and in the provinces, instant celeb status. i met a british guy in a tiny town in iloilo, he was fucking adored. like he was brad pitt and shit. the mayor even offered him a lot for free just so he would stay.

[–]manicpoohbear 1 point2 points ago

Even in Mindanao (where my family is from), it's the more Southern parts nowadays. A lot of the kidnappings are from the southern islands. My mom has a hankering to visit Palawan some day, and I'm a bit leery of that.

[–]flyladyj 0 points1 point ago

I'm white and visited Palawan. I went to Brooke's Point for a wedding. There is a certain km marker that it is advisable not to cross (I can't remember the number).

[–]PannyMacquiao 4 points5 points ago*

This is a throwaway account but I can say thanks for an AMA but I don't agree with the NPA's agendas at all.

I am a Filipino (Relatives up north in the Ilocos) and in the US Army. I participate in the yearly Balikatan exercises. I don't train the AFP how to fight but actually doing Civil Affairs/Humanitarian work and helping the people. I think we've done a lot more help for the Filipino communities there than what the NPA has done. We built schools, gotten kids school supplies, working restrooms, give livestock vitamins etc. and the people generally love us for it.

Don't get me wrong, I also think the Government is pretty corrupt there also but I don't see the NPA doing any better especially when most are doing more harm than good. But in the overall big picture, as person with Filipino ancestry, we do share a common goal of making the Philippines a better place.

Anyways, questions for you.

  • What have you personally done to help your people?
  • How do you feel about the Abu Sayif and other extreme Muslim groups there?
  • What kind of Beer do you like? (When I am there, Red Horse is my poison)
  • Do you guys also stop everything to watch the Manny Pacquiao fights?
  • Do you have Family in the states? If so, do they send you (or your Comrades) Balikbayan boxes filled with goodies? What kind of goodies?
  • Do you sing Karaoke? Even if it seems imperialist, what is your favorite American/Foreign song?
  • What is your Favorite Adobo style? (Mines will be forever Pork Adobo!)

Salamat!

Edit: Grammar and added another question.

[–]Fists_of_Fury 6 points7 points ago

What compelled you to join the NPA?

[–]NewPeoplesArmy[S] 2 points3 points ago

To improve the lives of the Filipino people.

[–]strathmeyer 2 points3 points ago

Yes, but what compelled you to improve the lives of the Filipino person? What does it mean to be a Filipino person? How is what you're doing improving the lives of the Filipino people? What do you do that improves the lives of the Filipino people?

[–]DonaldMcRonald 5 points6 points ago

What is best in life?

[–]superbadsoul 7 points8 points ago

To crush your enemies with the same amount of force, to see them driven before you at the same speed, and to hear the lamentations of their women in the same decibel level.

[–]DonaldMcRonald 2 points3 points ago

Possible, but logistically difficult.

[–]s0n0fk0ng 2 points3 points ago

How is this organization different from soviet, cuban and moaist revolutionary organizations. Can you expect a better outcome?

[–]jawndisease 2 points3 points ago

No you're not.

[–]purpleyam 2 points3 points ago

Sadly, the NPA had ideologies back then but these days they're nothing but a bunch of savage criminals.

Also, you're fake

[–]Dookiestain_LaFlair 23 points24 points ago

Are you using a computer that was built by capitalist pigs?

[–]Tashre 5 points6 points ago

Yes, but he's using open source linux, so it's all good.

[–]agnosticnixie 6 points7 points ago*

Since when do CEOs build computers? Most computers are built by chinese and thai workers, none of whom qualify as capitalists.

[–]NopeChomsky 14 points15 points ago

That's a stupid argument. Don't do that.

[–]Dookiestain_LaFlair 3 points4 points ago

Well most people are stupid, that's why it appeals to them.

[–][deleted] 5 points6 points ago

I know an 18 alpha headed to that area of the world next week. Good luck.

[–]jaki_cold 0 points1 point ago

Armed men fighting armed men fighting armed men! This makes perfect sense.

[–]sennais1 2 points3 points ago

I remember reading something in the paper here in Australia about the SAS starting to operate there as well.

These nut jobs don't stand a chance.

[–]nburghmatt 2 points3 points ago

what is an 18 alpha?

[–]MercatorMap 5 points6 points ago

US Army special forces officer.

[–]nburghmatt 1 point2 points ago

thanks

[–]MercatorMap 2 points3 points ago

No problem. The number indicates the "series" that they are in, basically what overall classification that they are, such as transportation, infantry, tanker, etc.

The letter indicates the specific job that they do. I.E. mechanized infantry, light infantry artillery (think mortars), scouts, etc.

[–]spast17 0 points1 point ago

Us special forces have been operating in the Philippines for a while in an" advisory" capacity. Although The Philippines have units specializing in Jungle Warfare, the rebels almost always have the upper hand as they are in their element. They don't just DO jungle warfare, they LIVE jungle warfare.

I don't believe this fight can be won by battle. It can only be won at the negotiating tables. Sadly, neither sides are willing to compromise. I don't foresee an end to this clusterfuck any time soon.

[–]ShetlandJames 0 points1 point ago

What do you think of East Timor? What are the chances it can develop in the future?

[–]wolfmanlenin 0 points1 point ago

I was wondering about your take on the recent split in the IPLS. If you don't want to comment on that however, I'll understand entirely.

[–]Eluriel 2 points3 points ago

What kind of literature do you base your struggle on? Please be specific :)

[–]Kirix 1 point2 points ago

What kind of military armaments do you have at your disposal?

[–]Gandalf_the_green 1 point2 points ago

What exactly makes you think a communist regime in the Philippines would work any better than any other corrupt communist regime around the world?

[–]iesalnieks 1 point2 points ago

What is your opinion on the anti communist peaceful revolutions that took place in Eastern Europe at the end of eighties and beginning of nineties.

[–]jiminee 0 points1 point ago*

Growing up, it was instilled in me that the NPA were the bad guys. I grew up in the Manila, so I was far from the war (either that, or I just chose to live in the Matrix and ignore everything that's not directly affecting me). Reading up on some of the comments here, it seems that your cause is good in the sense that you want to "save" the Filipino people.

I've always had this thought that all you guys have done is to (sorry for the lack of better word) terrorize the country. Kidnappings and killings wouldn't exactly portray you guys to be the hero now, would it? My question to you is, what are your group's objectives and what are the steps your group has done or are currently doing to achieve this? Why resort to war? Are you Robin Hood's merry men (steal from the rich, give to the poor)?

[–]nburghmatt 2 points3 points ago

i feel like more people should see this. Obama isn't a communist, this dude is a communist.

[–]chess86 2 points3 points ago

I'm from the Philippines and this guy is trolling you people.

[–]Talaial 2 points3 points ago

[–]BCBUDDHA 2 points3 points ago

Are you guys affiliated with the other phillipines group the M.I.L.F???

Do you feel the movie american pie and stiffler's mom have hurt their cause?

[–]Vertov_Bakunin 2 points3 points ago

this is fake. delete this.

[–]Meth_Useler 2 points3 points ago

Hey bro, I had an assignment in the past in which I "interacted" with you fuckers! Happy hunting to my brethren. You're a piece of shit. Don't AMA!

[–]Vultatio 2 points3 points ago

Am I the only one who thinks this AMA is fake as hell?

[–]purpleyam 1 point2 points ago

Most likely fake.

[–]flagamuffin 3 points4 points ago

Why do an AMA if you're so clearly biased? (I'm not faulting you for being biased -- you're human. I'm saying, your answers don't say much because they seem to have a PR lens filtering them, almost.)

[–]soylent_absinthe 1 point2 points ago

Your group is responsible for the violent murders of government employees in your country. You espouse the virtues of Maoism, which has impoverished millions and brutally crushes dissidents. You extort aid workers and volunteers.

I pretty much hope you get shot, unless you're planning on growing up sometime soon.

[–]series100262 0 points1 point ago

Capitalism isn't perfect, but it's far better than communism. Question: Who do you dislike more, the Japanese or the Americans and why?

[–]n1zm0 1 point2 points ago

my parents are from East M'sia, my relatives have many resort business interests on the coasts of Sabah, they have had many run-ins with the Abu Sayyaf stealing boat engines and resources for their own use, as a person with communist views, what do you think about their organization?

[–]NewPeoplesArmy[S] 2 points3 points ago*

The Abu Sayyafs should be killed. I don't believe in God. Religion is just something the imperialist brought in our country to brainwash the populace and control them. They kill people for something not worth fighting.

[–]dave_L 5 points6 points ago

Religion is just something the imperialist bought in our country...

And yet, that Religion was brought/introduced by Spaniards from time immemorial. But then, why singled out other Caucasians/Asians for kidnapping/extortions? And yet, nary a pure Espanol were in prominence for being a kidnapped/extorted victim. Why not go direct with the original source? Why on collateral victims instead?

[–]lol_u_so_kawaii 1 point2 points ago*

Hmm that this is the only thing that isn't downvoted to hell. Hmmm

[–]Unicornmayo 0 points1 point ago

Do you have any particular food or music you like? What does your average day as a rebel fighter look like?

[–][deleted] 3 points4 points ago

Are you part of the group traveling down killing foreigners in Sabah?

[–]RevDiesel 2 points3 points ago

cue crickets

[–]therealandrew 4 points5 points ago

Why do you have to be armed??

[–]NewPeoplesArmy[S] -1 points0 points ago

The only solution to a corrupt government is it to be destroyed. You can't improve the lives of the people if the corrupt government keeps stealing. They must killed to stop spread the greed and corruption brought by the imperialist Americans.

[–]FujiAppleYUM 6 points7 points ago

Once the corrupt government is destroyed, how can the people be better off under a communist system that gives them even less freedom?

[–]Im_Sarcastic 4 points5 points ago

So in order to stop the government stealing from the people you steal from the people to overthrow the government? Do you not see how fucking stupid that is?

[–]therealandrew 3 points4 points ago

The average American person is not a greedy imperialist. He is a normal person who at the end of the day only wants a job, a family and food on the table and could not care less about your political agendas. Could you see eye to eye with a American in that respect??

[–]NopeChomsky 1 point2 points ago

What about Gandhi? Is everything he did meaningless?

[–]agnosticnixie 1 point2 points ago

Gandhi burned down colonial buildings and the northern indian insurrection was very essential to the success of Gandhi's own rebellion.

[–]NopeChomsky 0 points1 point ago

Does revolution have to be violent to succeed?

[–][deleted] 0 points1 point ago

Shown in many cases over history, yes. As you will have noticed the American revolution was no walk in the park.

[–]NopeChomsky 0 points1 point ago

There has to be a way around mass bloodshed.

[–]ozthebawhs 2 points3 points ago

Man, get the fuck out. I appreciate the effort of trying to overthrow a government which is obviously not working but communism? Get the fuck out, that shit is a proven disaster - perhaps much like Capitalism, the difference being in the details.

Also, get the fuck out

[–][deleted] 0 points1 point ago

needGod.com

[–]Crotchfirefly 1 point2 points ago

You should really listen to this song:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHhrZgojY1Q

[–]Dr_Dolemite 1 point2 points ago

Thank you for the AMA. I do have some questions for you:

  1. How were you recruited? Did you volunteer? Besides political philosophy, was there anything in particular that motivated you to join?

  2. What contacts does your group have with international revolutionary movements? Do you have any role models for successful communist movements and governments?

  3. What is your relationship to the Catholic church? Do you have any specific plans for it if you should take power?

[–]bigkr88 1 point2 points ago

Alright, a list of questions I've always wanted to ask someone in a rebel communist movement:

Is there a general concern over government spies or turncoats within the organization? How do you deal with possible spies? Do you have spies in the government and phillipino army who feed you information?

Is there a plan covering the implementation of a communist government when you win? Who gets to sit at the top? Will it be a direct translation from how your movement is organized now, i.e. your current leaders will become the new leaders of the communist government?

How is your military forces organized? Do you follow a freeform, warband style where one man leads a large group? Do you have a hierarchy that extends past your local leaders? Where do your orders come from, or do you and your comrades operate independently of the greater communist party?

How are your weapons and supplies obtained? Do you rely on arms smugglers, or do you loot ambushed army groups? Is everyone armed, or do only a lucky portion obtain weapons? Or is there a kind of trial period where a new member will be weaponless until another army group is ambushed and new weapons are looted?

How are your living arrangements? Do you camp in the jungles, or are there permanent structures you reside in? Do you have access to electricity and running water? Do you have regular access to food and clean water? Do you have access to medical services if you need them for sickness, injuries from accidents, etc.? Are there periods of time where you are among the civilian populace but not in uniform, like for vacation?

How did you decide to do this AMA? Is this part of a wider public relations campaign by the NPA? Are your superiors aware of this AMA? Who is crafting responses, you or your superiors?

How are you guys getting internet in the jungle? How did you acquire the relatively new-looking laptop?

[–]LOLSTRALIA 1 point2 points ago

Kidnap foreign nationals like your Muslim friends and we'll turn your island into a missile test range.

just sayin.

[–]The_R4ke 1 point2 points ago

Hey I think this could be a fake. He didn't really provide any other background besides that picture, and it was on the first page of Images when I Googled New Peoples Army.

[–]morris858 0 points1 point ago

What exactly are you fighting against? What specific action by the current government do you hate the most? What pushed you over the edge and caused you to join the NPA?

[–]aktsukikeeper 0 points1 point ago

Is that considered verified? I mean, we don't even know the man in the photo is said OP or not. Anyway you write pretty well for a rebel fighter I would say.

[–]bl4ckb4dg3r5 1 point2 points ago

What historical communist movements do you look to? Do you have sympathies with the Maoists in India or Nepal? Or the anarchists struggling in Greece or in the West? What do you think about the Occupy movement?

Ideologically who are you close to? Lenin? Trotsky? Stalin? Or other communists? How much Marx do you study?

Thanks. I think this is pretty fucking cool to talk to you. Sorry to see you get downvoted by these capital loving imperialist sympathizers.

[–]jordazo 0 points1 point ago

Many people tend to relate the NPA with Abu-Sayyaf, what do you have to say to that comparison?

And maruong ka ba ng Tagalog na lang? Sinong translator para sayo?

[–]ProjectDirectory 0 points1 point ago

Why do you think Communism will work in the Philippines, since it hasn't worked anywhere else?

[–]Oba-mao 0 points1 point ago

How is Communism going to fix your country?

[–]rocketsfall 1 point2 points ago

Sooooo, based on how communism has worked for EVERY other country that has tried/still uses it, what in the hell makes you guys think that it'll work this time? what do you guys think you know that no one else did/does?

[–]icon_donnied 1 point2 points ago

Fuck you guys.. I was in a McDonalds in just outside of Angeles City in the late 80's when you guys opened up on it with automatic weapons. I still have a scar and a small piece of bullet bouncing around in my body.

[–]Raiancap 1 point2 points ago

Has the NPA solved the calculation problem yet?

[–]naglfar909 0 points1 point ago

What do you think about the Moro Islamic Liberation Front, or MILF in the Philippines?

[–]Herborist 0 points1 point ago

So, you're part of the rebels, eh? Was Darth Vader as tall as they said he was?

[–][deleted] 0 points1 point ago

Should tourist be afraid to visit the philippines? Keep in mind these same tourist keep local businesses going and keep people employed . What do you think about them in your country? Are they safe?

[–]xxdelta77xx 1 point2 points ago

You can google the NPA and get this picture immediately. If you open the associated article, you'll find his name is Jorge “Ka Oris” Madlos. Showing us an easily accessible picture of this man does not prove he is him and furthermore if you compare other articles with quotes from him to his writing here and in the comments you can tell its not him.

Move for deletion of this IAMA

[–]bazfoo222 0 points1 point ago

RIP, El Tigre.

[–]SgtMeowenstien 0 points1 point ago

Why are you such a dirty communist?

[–]Chances 0 points1 point ago

How about we agree not to down-vote this guy, for pure reddiquette sake?